Page 3 of 6
Posted: 11-06-2003 12:05
by NaB
heh do it as u like. Davidm asked me to do it the way i suggested (which no one objected to before it was done) but im not gonna sit here and sift through 100+ posts of spam an nominations and write down ppls choices manually.
Allstar votes are polls.. in RL the nominees are selected by the press or whatever and ppl are allowed to pick 2 in each category. one so they can pick the player they are biased towards and one to pick the player they actually think is the best. But i guess this messed up cos ppl didnt know what to do with the 2nd vote after they voted for a friend so they just picked tezc or cy
i guess it is stupid cos a lot of great players from lower divisions arent there. didnt think ppl would get so worked up about it though =(
Posted: 11-06-2003 12:22
by R3L!K
yeah, there's no deus or aov players in the poll....
Posted: 11-06-2003 12:26
by NaB
but whos gonna pick what lower division teams are represented and which ones are not..
Posted: 11-06-2003 12:54
by klesk
btw. i never saw a player TEZC-JollyRulez and i think it wud be very boring for everybody to see another match tezc-d + 1L vs. cy13.
Posted: 11-06-2003 12:58
by klesk
NaB wrote:
but whos gonna pick what lower division teams are represented and which ones are not..
just the teams that will be in div1 next season
Posted: 11-06-2003 13:05
by Cyph
NaB wrote:
heh all my hard work :p
but i agree. seems most ppl have voted for tag rather than player in the current one =(
Problem is that I can't vote for players I've never seen play. I've never played against cY.blue and never played against half of their players in any game at all, so how can I vote for them? In contrast I've played TEZC more times than I can count, and know how good all of their players are, so those are most likely to be the ones I vote for.
Posted: 11-06-2003 13:19
by DavidM
well, i stated my opinion on this, now I am waiting for the other league admins
Posted: 11-06-2003 13:58
by Fruitcake
There are tons of good players out there that arent even mentioned here... sum which i think have more ability and talent than the ones chosen
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/924b6/924b63674789b3579e4083dd95e7bd052dc99a5b" alt="roll eyes (sarcastic) :rolleyes:"
Posted: 11-06-2003 14:40
by Axl
But i guess this messed up cos ppl didnt know what to do with the 2nd vote after they voted for a friend so they just picked tezc or cy
or their 1st vote went to a friend also..
As a side note i only voted for 2 TEZC members
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/62905/629051233c453d1f64adc7d201b8f4be5d648d21" alt="tongue :P"
i actually did go for people i generally thought were the better players and not "Team mates" or "friends"
I personnaly never liked this idea anyway.. was to much like eurovision.. ie its all political and not done cos they are actually better players, just better known in the db community
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d983f/d983f7d4b9470bd04655bda63d15ba7c568d5588" alt="smile :)"
Posted: 11-06-2003 15:37
by [1234]Jr
Surge wrote:
why all-star games suck:
Players often have conflicting talents
On every team theres usually 1 main scorer. Lets just say having 2 on the same team doesnt work as well... if your going to have an all-star game pick the top 6 ranked teams and have them elect 2 players to participate. 1 on each team will obviously warm the bench but its the only logical way to do it.
stfu, for once - i not read the rest of the pages, just ur post and the 1st b4 :d so just stop puttin everything down tart, if u dont like it take a hike
Posted: 11-06-2003 15:42
by Bazzi
What if I dont like either idea? :p
Posted: 11-06-2003 15:46
by BL44T
Keep: Gimic
Def: Gobby - HorIzoN
Att: Catalyst - Morning*Star
Posted: 11-06-2003 15:58
by Hellbringer
DavidM wrote:
we know it from pickups what it is like
we played with cy13 against a pickup, and we had serious trouble beating them
was 2:1 or so in the end x_X
Hehe i loved that match and it was 3 - 1 not bad for a pickup. team.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fb918/fb918c3e93d160fa5cd97b336b6063be44c08523" alt="happy :D"
Posted: 11-06-2003 16:17
by [1234]Jr
Bazzi wrote:
What if I dont like either idea? :p
But you dont slag off everything everywhere
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fb918/fb918c3e93d160fa5cd97b336b6063be44c08523" alt="happy :D"
Posted: 11-06-2003 16:23
by R3L!K
isn't the national teams thing a bit like the all stars thing anyway?
we're picking the best players from certain regions, thats the only difference...