GazMaN wrote:
i agree with it largely, i justr completely disagree with the fact that just 2 ppl are responsible for giving ppl ratings and also keeping them secret!
i agree ppl dont need to know their ratings cos like david says it would cause conflicts, but in no way shud him and goldy be solely responsible for sorting ratings out!
that david and i are the only ones responsible for rating players is only a temporary solution. it takes time to build a voting system, that will be able to keep track of votes from and for over 500 people that are currently in the bots database. (all of those have been active in #dbpickup the last 30 days)
but it still has to be decided in what way voting will be. either only ops will be allowed to vote for someone at anytime, everyone has one vote for each player that he can use anytime, or players of a pickup may vote for each others ratings. (or any other good suggestion)
and being rated high doesn't mean you'll never play with good players, there are usually many possibilities to arrange teams in a fair way.
if anyone notices a really biased pickup (score like 1x-0 or similar) tell me, all pickups are currently logged so player ratings and the algorithm can be optimised.